If you know my views on Israel’s Rabbinic courts and the wider family law system, you know I am often critical of them. However, this case is an exception, and I believe the Dayanim (religious court judges) got it right. Consider someone who signed a prenuptial agreement with a non-Jewish partner. Why would they assume that a later conversion and Jewish wedding would cancel that agreement? This is especially puzzling when a large income is involved. Read my summary below and feel free to share your thoughts.
The Dayanim (religious court judges) of a Rabbinical Court ruled on the case. The husband was a wealthy businessman with a huge income. They found that he had started the divorce. Therefore, he had to pay his wife her Dmei ketubah of 260,000 NIS. The Dmei ketubah is the sum owed to a wife under her Jewish wedding contract.
The wife did not give up the Dmei ketubah. She also claimed the compensation in the financial agreement signed before their civil marriage. That agreement was signed several years before their religious marriage in the Rabbinate. It entitled her to 50,000 NIS for each year of marriage.
The couple married civilly because the woman was not Jewish. Before that marriage, they signed the financial agreement. Over the next few years, the woman converted to Judaism. Then the Rabbinate married the couple again. At this second ceremony, the husband signed a ketubah (Jewish wedding contract) for 260,000 NIS.
About a year later, the husband decided to divorce. This followed many police complaints the wife had filed against him.
The woman also showed that the husband had cheated on her repeatedly. In fact, he had even had a vasectomy so that his mistresses would not become pregnant.
The husband argued that once the Rabbinate married them, he meant the ketubah sum to replace the divorce compensation in the financial agreement. Therefore, he said, it should be offset against that compensation.
The Dayanim explained why courts usually offset property payments against the ketubah. Typically, on divorce, husbands will not agree to pay both sums. However, this case was different. The husband was a financial tycoon, earning in the top tenth of a percent. He could easily pay both the ketubah and the compensation he had originally agreed to.
Therefore, the Dayanim ruled that the husband must pay the wife her ketubah of 260,000 NIS. This amount would not be offset against the compensation in the financial agreement.