Property Division Without a Prenuptial Agreement


Couples tend to avoid two main topics: money and sex. I have nothing groundbreaking to say about sex. However, when it comes to money in a relationship, I have plenty of insights. I specialize in prenuptial agreements, and there’s a reason why. Proper planning can prevent a lot of unnecessary pain.

Whenever couples I work with divorce, I advise them to sign an agreement before their next relationship begins. This applies even if they choose not to marry legally, as in a common-law marriage. A recent case brought this issue before a judge. The couple had been married for 15 years and kept separate bank accounts the whole time. They never had a joint account. Nor did they sign a prenup before or during the marriage.

Their relationship hit a rough patch in October 2019, when they sued each other. The husband argued that they had kept their finances separate from the start. Therefore, he said, the Financial Relations Law, which calls for equal division, should not apply to them. He also argued that his car accident settlement and the cash he had before marriage should not be split.

The woman, on the other hand, relied on the Financial Relations Law, which covers assets built up during the relationship. Under it, she argued, their joint property should be shared. This included NIS 100,000 her ex-husband received for a car accident. It also included another NIS 300,000 withdrawn from his accounts in unclear circumstances.

In addition, she asked to divide certain real estate her ex-husband bought before they married. After all, they had lived together for about 16 years without a prenuptial agreement.

The judge rejected all of the husband’s claims, because the couple had no prenuptial agreement. “For couples who haven’t signed a prenuptial agreement approved by a court, the Financial Relations Law steps in to govern them, rendering the man’s property separation claims legally baseless.”

A prenuptial agreement is crucial. In fact, advice from an attorney experienced with these agreements can help keep the couple’s relationship intact. Read our eBook on prenups to learn more about why they matter: https://jayhaitlaw.com/ebook_prenuptial/