Property Division Without a Prenuptial Agreement

Couples tend to avoid two main topics: money and sex. I don’t have much insight on the latter. However, when it comes to money in relationships, I have plenty to share. Prenuptial agreements are one of my areas of expertise, and there’s a reason for that. Proper planning can prevent needless pain later on.

Whenever I help clients through a divorce, I advise them to sign an agreement before their next serious relationship. This applies even if they choose not to marry legally, because common-law marriages also have financial consequences. A recent case showed the risks of not having a prenuptial agreement.

A couple had been married for 15 years and had always maintained separate bank accounts. They never shared a joint account or signed a prenup before or during their marriage. Their relationship took a turn in October 2019, leading them to file lawsuits against each other in court.

The husband argued that they had kept their finances separate from the start. Therefore, he said, the Financial Relations Law, which requires equal division of assets, should not apply to them. He also claimed that his car accident settlement and the money he had before the marriage should stay his alone.

The wife, on the other hand, argued that under the Financial Relations Law, all assets built up during the marriage were shared. She wanted to include the NIS 100,000 her husband received as accident compensation. She also included another NIS 300,000 withdrawn from his accounts in unclear circumstances. In addition, she asked to divide real estate her husband bought before the marriage. After all, they had lived together for 16 years without a prenuptial agreement.

The judge ruled against the husband, emphasizing that without a prenuptial agreement, the Financial Relations Law automatically applied. His claims of financial separation were deemed legally baseless.

This case underscores the importance of having a prenuptial agreement. Seeking legal advice from an attorney experienced in such matters can protect both partners and help preserve their relationship. Proper planning today can prevent legal battles tomorrow.