How Did It Happen That the Court Had to Decide Whether a Daughter Would Join a Trip to Poland?

Sometimes divorced parents cannot agree on an important decision about their child’s life. Then the court must decide for them. That is exactly what happened to the parents of a 16-year-old girl. They asked the Family Court in Jerusalem to decide whether she could travel to Poland with her class.

The mother wanted to let her daughter join this well-known, meaningful educational trip. The father strongly objected. He argued that the girl was especially sensitive and that the trip might cause her serious emotional harm. This was particularly true after October 7, which had already shaken her deeply. In addition, he claimed that the global security situation and rising anti-Semitism made the trip dangerous.

According to their divorce agreement, any trip abroad required the written consent of both parents. When the mother approached the father to get his approval, he refused to respond. As a result, she filed a motion asking the court to authorize the trip without his signature.

What Did the Judge Decide?

The judge appointed a guardian ad litem, who met with the teenager. The girl said clearly that she understood the trip would be emotionally complex. Still, she felt strong enough to cope and very much wanted to take part like every other student in her class. She called the journey “an experience she was not willing to miss.”

In her decision, the judge wrote that she gave real weight to the girl’s sincere, clear position. She also gave weight to the girl’s belief in her own ability to handle the experience.

The father’s claims of health and psychological risks were not supported by any concrete evidence. Likewise, the general claim about security threats and antisemitism was not proven.

The Outcome?

The court allowed the teenager to travel to Poland with her school group. It also let the mother get her a passport without the father’s signature. In addition, the father was ordered to pay 1,000 shekels in legal costs.

What Can We Learn from This Case?

Parents sometimes deeply disagree about educational matters, especially major trips. In those cases, the court carefully weighs the child’s best interests. Sometimes it also gives real weight to the child’s mature wishes.